Friday, 26 September 2008

Send me a PS3 and we’ll call it quits


The ‘complex’ theory of corporate tat says that if you send me a poloshirt, baseball cap, laser pen, memory stick, calculator, document holder, rucksack, business card holder or indeed any other vaguely useful item that I will use the gift and be reminded of your client’s firm the next time I see their name and then I might write about them.

Chances are though, that as soon as I’m out of your sight (sometime not even then) I will throw it all in the bin. I would give it away to a tramp, but even vagabonds and junkies would rather not wear your branded t-shirts.

Another slightly less popular strategy with the freebie is to go a bit over the top and hope this curries favour. In all honesty it works better than the one outlined above though it carries a few risks, not least the expense.

The corporate gift is dodgy territory. It’s Operation Backhander. We know the score. It’s bribery. In some cultures it is a serious no-no, in others it is positively expected. But some ‘gifts’ aren’t worth the price of the overly expensive branded, never-to-be-used-more-than-once, bags that they come in.

I was once sent a cigarette lighter with a fiver wrapped around it, enclosed in the envelope was a note, the PR had written, “is your money going up in smoke?”

The firm, hilariously enough, was a disaster recovery company that went out of business.

Can’t think why.

Wednesday, 24 September 2008

The back door

I stopped answering my phone every time it rang a long time ago. I've got a post-it stuck on the phone with a list of numbers on it, which is both a blacklist and a whitelist depending on deadlines, my mood, the position of the moon, etc. And I suspect I'm not the only hack who screens calls like this.

But PRs have obviously cottoned on as they've become ever inventive in their attempts to get through. There's the 'External call' coming through from the PRs corporate exchange (might get picked up); the 'Unknown number' from someone calling the customer service desk and getting transferred (never gets picked up); and then there's the ones where actual numbers show up so I can Caller ID them (always gets picked up), unless its (never gets picked up).

We've seen all the tricks - call from a mobile phone so you get a different number; call from a mobile with 'Private number' switched on; call reception at the office; and call someone on the same team who sits nearby and get transferred.

But there's this other one as well - the back door. Call a random number at the company the journo works for and get them to transfer the call. So if I see an internal call coming through from someone I don't know, I know what's coming: there'll be a flustered colleague on the other end who thinks they've got a really important call for me, which they need to transfer, and if I don't answer they'll feel obliged to take a message.

These people aren't my fucking receptionists, they just happen to work with me. So I feel obliged to answer these calls, inevitably to find that the 'important call' is just some flack pitching a press release.

Annoyingly this tactic was used twice the other day, by the same person. I fielded a back door call and gave the PR in question my email address, only to have her call back ten minutes later using the same trick to check I received the press release (the most pointless and annoying kind of call).

It's a dirty trick. If you can't find a journalist's direct line, or even their email address (hint: it's usually on the website/magazine/newsletter/paper they write for), using all the 21st century tools you have at your disposal, you're not very good at your job and might be better placed selling debt management to people who watch daytime TV all day.

At least then the machines dial the numbers for you.

Tuesday, 23 September 2008

His name is Earl

We’ve been added to the blogroll of one Steve Earl http://www.rainierpr.co.uk/earl/. He’s the managing director of Rainier PR, a tech PR firm based in London.

He’s got some interesting views this lad. Not least of which is his suggestion that the credit crunch could be a good time to start up a tech PR firm.

“Tech PR seems to be holding its own in this country, but equally several agencies have been laying people off recently. It’s not a time for the faint-hearted, but my guess is that the strong will shine through and we’ll see several hot tech PR start-ups born over the next year that become the next generation of challengers,” he says.

Does that mean the credit crunch is bad for Bad PR?

Not likely, transparent attempts to angle, or rather mangle, tech firms’ products into stories loosely based on the collapse of Lehman Brothers or the troubles at HBOS are as plentiful as they are irrelevant.

I know taking a current affairs story of national/global importance and then working your client in somehow is a common trick, but it is seldom effective. It’s just a waste of everyone’s time.

“The US is failing to win over ‘hearts and minds’ in Iraq. Would you be interested in talking with Dave Smith, VP of product marketing for Dullco Customer Relationship Management firm about his firm’s holistic communications strategy?”

No.

Some firms are doing well, it’s true, but it doesn’t that mean that they’re “bucking the credit crunch trend”. Honestly, your client got another round of funding. Good for them. It’s not a story though.

I look forward to interacting with the hot tech PR start-ups that Steve thinks will be born out of the current financial crisis. Who knows, maybe Bad PR will take on a few clients.

A last minute reprieve

In the nick of time (thanks to a sales enforced extension to the deadline) an article for the supplement was submitted at 5:41 last night..!

This doesn't make for particularly entertaining reading on Bad PR. But in the interests of fair play and because Bad PR came Good in the end, I guess I'd better leave the posts up...

Friday, 19 September 2008

Mended promises?

Following on from yesterday's rant regarding being let down on contrib just one day before deadline. The agency in question has come up with a last gasp attempt to save the day. I just received this:

Hi Fin,

Further to this, the CTO has suggested that he would be able to draft an article for you by Monday. I know you would prefer a different exec and that this is beyond the deadline you told us, but if there was any way you could wait until Monday, the CTO would be able to get this over to you.

Please let me know whether this might be acceptable and apologies again for the difficulties we have had with this.

Kind Regards,

PR

Hmmm, not the right person and well past deadline would usually mean curtains. However, there is another group of people whose existence, while necessary, causes journos even more pain than PRs: Salesmen. When they haven't sold, deadlines get moved. That's just the way it goes. The PR, by a twist of fate, has got more time....

The deadline is Monday, the PR has got the weekend to come up with the goods. Will they make it into the supplement?

Only time will tell......

Thursday, 18 September 2008

Broken promises

We’re putting together a supplement for a trade show at the mo. We’ve interviewed the CTO of the organisation behind the trade show and would be including that, but in addition the agency that represents the organisation behind the trade show was given the opportunity of penning a piece for the supplement.

That’s two pages of prime editorial FREE. It is, in PR terms, gold dust.

Two weeks before the supplement copy deadline I was sent an invitation to the show. I replied saying:

Cool thanks – I think The Escapist mentioned a contrib feature. Did your client mention anything?

The PR said:

Don't think she did, but I will check for you. Was there any particular topic/author that you guys had in mind?

I said:

I’m afraid I’m not sure on the details. I could be mistaken. I just thought I’d heard the Escapist talking about getting a contrib feature. I guess the CEO would be preferable. Not sure on topic, the CTO interview is fairly general so maybe digging deeper into the plans for the Organisation. I’d be open to suggestions.

The following Monday I sent this:

Hi PR

Hope all is well. Has there been any movement on a contrib feature for the supplement?

Cheers
Fin

I got this:

Hi Fin,

I have been speaking with the Client and we are looking into possible ideas for a contributed article. We are definitely keen to do this - when would you need the article by? At the moment we are thinking of a feature looking at something very relevant to The Client - does this sound like something that would be interesting? I know that you mentioned something else, but there have been no real developments on this front recently, and we feel the topic may not be relevant to those outside The Client and its partners, so it might be better to get a wider-focused feature instead. We are looking into whether it would be possible to get this by-lined to the CEO, but this may not be possible. The CTO is one of our favourite writers at The Client, but since your original interview was with him, would you prefer the article to come from someone else?

Let me know your thoughts.

Kind Regards,

PR

I said:

Hi PR

We need the piece by the end of this week and about 1600 words. Your suggestions on the topic area look good. I would prefer not to byline the CTO. Purely because the feature interview is of CTO, and it would look better for The Client and us if a different exec is bylined.

How does that sound?

Cheers
Fin

She said:

Hi Fin,

That sounds great. We will find somebody other than the CTO to write the article for you and get it to you by the end of the week. I will let you know if there are any problems.

Kind Regards,

PR


A day later I was sent this:

Hi Fin,

On the article for the show supplement, The Client are keen to get their VP Developer Product Marketing, to write the article. However, he would only be able to do this by next Friday (26th), rather than the end of this week, as you requested. Would this be alright? Let me know if not, and we can find someone else to write it to get it to you this week.

Kind Regards,

PR

I said:

Hi PR

I’m afraid the deadline is very definitely the end of this week. We can’t shift it, sorry about that
Cheers
Fin

A day later, one day before deadline, I got this:

Hi Fin,

We're so sorry to do this at such short notice, but unfortunately, we are not going to be able to provide the article by the end of tomorrow. We have been searching high and low for an exec who would be able to get this done, but in this time-frame we are just not able to get it turned around. Please let us know if there is any other way we might be able to help you to fill this space, as we are aware this is leaving you short-handed. Me and A Colleague are out of the office this afternoon, but I have included our mobile numbers below in case you want to speak to us about this.

Apologies again for the short notice, we have tried our utmost to find someone to write this, but it just isn't possible.

Kind Regards,

PR

Let me run that by you again….

“..but in this time-frame we are just not able to get it turned around”

They’ve had two effin’ weeks to pen a 1600 word article. How much time-frame does it take?

More spinpox spotted


This isn’t really Bad PR, it’s really Bad Journalism.

The BBC reported today that the RAC Foundation has discovered that reading and sending text messages while driving is dangerous.

Whatever next?

Riding a bicycle with your eyes closed is hazardous.

Flying a kite in a thunderstorm is crazy.

Fighting a polar bear in Speedos is suicidal.

Copying press releases is lazy.